Should Western Canada Leave Confederation 3

Forum for the discussion of the Feldsted Friends newsletter.
Post Reply
John Feldsted
Posts: 172
Joined: Fri Jan 10, 2020 11:45 am

Should Western Canada Leave Confederation 3

Post by John Feldsted »

The creation of a Western Canada is not an easy undertaking and cannot succeed without widespread public support. In the wake of anxiety over the shut down of the gas and oil sector and more anxiety over the coronavirus threat, people are in no mood to take risks with an unfamiliar governing model. They are not going to jump over a cliff.

Several readers have expressed a preference for forming a Republic rather than a Constitutional Monarchy. That is not a panacea or solution. There are 147 Republics word wide. Of those only 28 have ministries subject to parliamentary confidence. 62 including the United Stated have a president independent of the legislature. I am not opposed to a Republic, but creating a workable republic will take even more work and we are then proposing a marked difference from familiar governance.

The Western Canada model has to closely resemble the current Canada model. That is why I am recommending the use of the BNA Act as a template, modified to meet Western Canada needs. I will go further an recommend that we retain the Monarch as our Head of State and apply to become a Commonwealth nation. There are currently 30 Constitutional Monarchies in the world. Andorra, Antigua and Barbuda, Australia, The Bahamas, Barbados, Belgium, Belize, Cambodia, Canada, Denmark, Grenada, Jamaica, Japan, Lesotho, Luxembourg, Malaysia, Monaco, Netherlands, New Zealand, Norway, Papua New Guinea, Saint Kitts and Nevis, Saint Lucia, Saint Vincent and the Grenadines. Solomon Islands, Spain, Sweden, Thailand, Tuvalu & United Kingdom.

There are sound reasons for that approach. If Western Canada is accepted by Great Britain and other Commonwealth nations, we have solid allies worldwide that can help us find our feet and it will frustrate forces that try to block us.

That is why I would recommend applying to the United Nations for recognition and membership. We should also open talks with the USA and Mexico for recognition and inclusion in the new NAFTA and inclusion in NORAD. We need to leverage our military bases in Alberta and Manitoba as well as marine bases on the West Coast which are all vital to North American defence.

People need assurance that their governance and legal systems will be unchanged, except that they will be more efficient, effective and responsive.

We need to have international recognition and support so we can negotiate on an equal basis with Canada. We will not approach Canada hat-in-hand seeking permission to succeed. Canada will have do deal with an accomplished fact.

We would adopt most of the Canadian legal system modified where necessary. Our Criminal Code should mirror the Canadian Criminal code with modification to the firearms section. Our citizens should know that familiar law will not be much different than what they are used to. We have no reason to import the Firearms Act, Official Languages Act or much of the convoluted environmental legislation. Our provincial governments are capable stewards of air, land and water quality.

The largest single problem that Canada has is that the amendment of its constitution is nearly impossible. It is locked into a constitution that does not address many modern issues that did not exist a century ago. Western Canada can overcome that with a more flexible constitution that will allow us to correct errors and missteps inevitable in forming a new nation.

A key is open public engagement from the outset. Once a draft constitution is completed, it has to be shared with the public before adoption. People need to see what they are being asked to support. The same goes for other key pieces of legislation such as the Criminal Code, the Elections Act and the Parliament Act.

We need to build the infrastructure to ensure that provincial residents can elect 104 members of the Western Canada Parliament to properly shepherd the new nation into being. They answer to the people who elected hem. We can, and should amend that Parliament Act that we adopt to prohibit political parties from dictating to elected representatives. They are there to represent their constituents, not anyone or anything else.

Similarly, residents can elect two Senators from each province to serve a fixed term. Senators have to swear an oath of political neutrality to take their seats. Their job is to review legislation and policies strictly on the terms of benefits or detriments to the people of their province. That is the proper function of a Senate.

These are more of the issues that need fulsome discussion and debate before launching an effort to create a Western Canada. I have avoided the separation debate largely because I have felt that the key elements have not been adequately discussed.

Getting angry and walking out is not viable. When that door slams, we have to have a workable plan that has been lacking. Western Canada will be responsible for the lives, liberty and well-being of about 12 million people. We can’t manage that without sound planning and enormous preparations that are part of it.

More later.

User avatar
Ursus
Posts: 247
Joined: Fri May 15, 2020 6:00 pm

Re: Should Western Canada Leave Confederation 3

Post by Ursus »

Very true that we cannot simply walk out. Everything has to be in place before there is secession. The ball is rolling and let it keep doing so, with careful thought out planning. We do not need to create a bigger political and economic mess than Canada is already in.
Da pacem, Domine, in diebus nostris
Quia non est alius
Qui pugnet pro nobis
Nisi tu Deus noster.

User avatar
Duane Berke
Posts: 238
Joined: Fri Jan 31, 2020 12:14 pm

Re: Should Western Canada Leave Confederation 3

Post by Duane Berke »

In my view here, there are two things that come next.

Alberta has to leave the Canada Pension Plan and establish its own program apart from POTawa. What's good enough for PAYbec is good enough for Alberta.

Secondly, the RCMP have to be profoundly thanked for their primarily rural service and asked to depart Alberta as the Alberta Sheriff's department is vastly expanded. It's entirely inappropriate (and offensive) to be policed by POTawa and perhaps a conflict of interest given the state of welfare transfer extortions with Alberta being held hostage for billions annually as a defacto colony.
"When you get to the end zone, act like you've been there before." - Vince Lombardi
Harley-Davidson XL1200CX Roadster. Black Bikes Matter.

User avatar
Ursus
Posts: 247
Joined: Fri May 15, 2020 6:00 pm

Re: Should Western Canada Leave Confederation 3

Post by Ursus »

RCMP/GRC......although your memory will linger on, true Albertans will be glad when you’ve gone.

High River Remembered
Da pacem, Domine, in diebus nostris
Quia non est alius
Qui pugnet pro nobis
Nisi tu Deus noster.

Post Reply