Should Western Canada Leave Confederation 2

Forum for the discussion of the Feldsted Friends newsletter.
Post Reply
John Feldsted
Posts: 173
Joined: Fri Jan 10, 2020 11:45 am

Should Western Canada Leave Confederation 2

Post by John Feldsted »

To properly understand the impetus for confederation, we have to go back to 1841 and the British Parliament Act of Union that joined Upper and Lower Canada into one Province of Canada. Each of the former provinces would elect an equal number of representatives to a central Parliament.

Lower Canada was annoyed as Upper Canada had a population of about 450,000 while Lower Canada had a population of about 650,000. The result was that no political leader could draw enough support from the ‘other side’ to form a majority government.

Elections were held in 1841,1844, 1848,1851, 1854, 1858, 1981, and 1863 without a workable government being elected. The notion of joining with other provinces to break the deadlock led to talks between Upper Canada, Nova Scotia, and New Brunswick. Quebec joined the talks.

All provinces were concerned over a potential American invasion as the American Civil War had ended in 1865 and the US had an ample army in uniform to invade and annex Canada. Quebec was particularly concerned as she feared that if America invaded and won, she would lose the rights she was granted by the Quebec Act of 1778.

The main reasons for confederation were to break the political deadlock in the Province of Canada and unify to fight off a potential American invasion. There was no thought of creating a wider Confederation or anything that did not protect the enjoined provinces of Upper and Lower Canada.

The British North America Act of 1867 clearly reflected the importance of Ontario and Quebec and made it clear that they were the central core of the confederation. Nothing has changed since.

In 1869, Canada purchased Rupert’s Land from the Hudson’s Bay Company with considerable pressure from the British government. The Hudson’s Bay Company wanted to sell to the US at a higher price. When the federal government tried to install a governor in the Red River Settlements, he faced a rebellion and the Province of Manitoba was created (1870). The construction of a railway brought British Columbia into Confederation (1871). These efforts were to vastly expand the territory under the control of Canada. There was no thought of creating strong provinces or equality of any sort.

When the area between Manitoba and British Columbia were under settlement, the federal government feared a strong province might appear which would become a political problem, so it split the territory into Alberta and Saskatchewan.

From the outset and creation of the British North America Act to today, the intention is to concentrate political power in Ontario and Quebec and that has been succeeded so far. Immigration has kept populations in those provinces high and between them, they hold 58.8% of Commons seats and 45.7% of the Senate seats. Since the Senate is split along party lines despite efforts to show otherwise, Liberal control of the Senate is even stronger.

The die is cast and we cannot look to constitutional amendments to improve our lot. We face a stark choice of remaining a subsidiary controlled by Ottawa or striking out on our own.

User avatar
Posts: 329
Joined: Fri May 15, 2020 6:00 pm

Re: Should Western Canada Leave Confederation 2

Post by Ursus »

I believe the Fathers of Confederation wanted to create a strong federal system with weak provinces as not to have the issue the US did with secession/state’s rights.

They were worried too about a Yankee invasion since the South was now subdued and most Indians wiped out or taken care of.

Canada was this born as a result of the US War of Southern Annihilation.
Blessed be the Lord my God, who teacheth my hands to fight,
and my fingers to war.


User avatar
Duane Berke
Posts: 286
Joined: Fri Jan 31, 2020 12:14 pm

Re: Should Western Canada Leave Confederation 2

Post by Duane Berke »

The BNA Act or how Canada was drawn up is irrelevant. Alberta has 6 Senators. Nova Scotia and New Brunswick have 10. NL has 6 and PEI has 4 - two less than Alberta with the population of metro Red Deer. A prairie hick town.

The point of "law" is meaningless at this point. Alberta should halt welfare extortions tomorrow morning and declare its intentions, as well as filing with the World Court for repayment and restitution for what amounts to slavery and billions upon billions of dollars extorted every year.
"When you get to the end zone, act like you've been there before." - Vince Lombardi
Harley-Davidson XL1200CX Roadster. Black Bikes Matter

Post Reply